Cól-lee, a Band Chief (Cherokee), painted by George Catlin (1834)
Below please find this week’s web questions written by your classmate, Nicky Bangs. He wrote quite a few questions, but you need to respond to just one or two in your comments.
1) Why does Wallace claim that white inhabitants of the South feared the so-called “Five Civilized Tribes” more than the “savage Indians?”
2) Wallace puts forth the claim that not all white men of the early nineteenth century felt Indians were inferior; many saw them as untutored men with equal reasoning abilities to white men. But were there any whites who truly had no prejudice? Doesn’t the notion of “civilizing” another group of people suggest prejudice in itself?
3) What methods–either intentional or unintentional–other than conquest were used to drive natives from their land?
4) Is there any merit to Cass’s “hunter state” theory? What are its pitfalls? What aspects of Native American culture does it neglect to acknowledge?
5) How did white Northerners and Southerners differ in their perceptions of and interactions with the neighboring Indian tribes?
6) Was the U.S. breaking any laws in executing the Indian removals? If so, which ones? Do you think that the fact that the Cherokee wrote their own constitution as a sovereign nation had any effect on the morality of the removals?